Of My Own Freewill and Accord

I’ve always been curious about the peculiar practice in Freemasonry that no man may be asked, invited, or solicited to enter the fraternity. It is an organizational feature almost unique among societies. In fact, organizations with the most select membership are those which receive no applications, but select and invite their candidates.

The no-ask/no-tell canon has been a rule of immemorial standing in the fraternity and, yet, it is impossible to determine when it originated. There is nothing concerning it in the Gothic Constitutions, nor in any of the rules and by-laws of the old lodges, or in the Constitutions of 1723; nor is it discussed by any of the Masonic writers of the 18th Century.

There is nothing in the ritual on the subject. The “candidate interrogatories” written by William Preston asks only that the candidate affirm he comes to Freemasonry unbiased by an improper solicitation. And yet, we know that men of noble rank were solicited to become Grand Masters, though they were not Freemasons and had to be initiated just for that purpose.

So, all this begs some questions–if we come to Freemasonry by our own free will and accord, in what way are we free? Masonically, what does it mean to be free men? Is this freedom important? Once we enter and take on the commitments and obligations of our fraternity, does this make us less free?

Perhaps there is something to be learned by reflecting on the meaning of being free men in the context that Freemasonry is a “system of morality veiled in allegory.” These three words, “system of morality” may be at the core of our understanding of being free-men, or free-masons. Certainly, these words would be a reason why we should insist that all men who join us do so with complete freedom. Freedom is a condition sine qua non for joining an order based on morality.



That a person enters of his own free will and accord means that he is a man free from all prejudices and attitudes which are not based on his own self examination; that he is prepared to judge all attitudes, including his own, with intellectual integrity; that he is free and ready to make a moral judgment and to defend it even when he is in the minority or under strain for holding such a view; and, even more important, that he is aware he must place limits on his own freedom if he is to insure other men the same right to theirs.

There is a thin line between being free and being just; between dividing one’s obligations with one’s rights; in self-censoring our own freedom as a result of recognizing another has the same right to his own; that the moral norms of one country may be different in another, yet both right; that the majority recognize the minority’s point of view and that the minority accept the right of the majority to bind all by its decisions. One becomes morally free only when his individual independence is balanced by intelligent choice.

To be moral and to act in accordance with moral values requires the ability and readiness to judge between right and wrong, between what is in conformity with prevailing norms and what is not. A moral choice can only exist if it rests on choosing between two possible alternatives; and this choice has to be made with complete freedom and with no coercion of any kind. A man determines his sense of morals only when these are put to the test. If the choice he makes is made under coercion, there is no moral value in his choice.

To be a Freemason means we possess fundamental moral attitudes which are based on constant self evaluation and re-evaluation of every aspect of our life. The opening charge to the Master Mason in the 4° of the Scottish Rite is worthy of our contemplation. “Freemasonry is an institution seeking human happiness through tolerance and love; self-perfection, glorifying justice, truth and equality; fighting tyranny, ignorance and prejudices.”

To achieve this definition means that every Brother must approach free objectivity in his moral choices. We may think of freedom only in a sense of being free from restrictions or limitations. However, this is perhaps the lesser freedom. The freedom to act according to our freely-made moral choices and convictions is what makes us true Freemasons.

Are we less free as a result of undertaking such commitments together as Brothers? I think not. In fact, we have chosen of “our own free will and accord” to be committed to certain moral values.

To me, this is a true expression of being free.

Previous Posts

Operative Freemasons

Operatives In the Middle Ages and until about 1500 the Operative Masons were not organized as Medieval Stonemasons Speculative Freemasons are. The builders as a whole,

First Degree Working Tools of the Freemasons

As soon as we begin to study and meditate upon the working tools of the first degree we perceive almost at a glance that these tools were by no means

The Book of Hiram – Freemasonry, Venus, and the Secret Key to the Life of Jesus

Christopher Knight - The Book of Hiram Christopher Knight - The Book of Hiram - Freemasonry, Venus, and the Secret Key to the Life of Jesus - Full Book in


MORALS and DOGMA by ALBERT PIKE Morals and Dogma of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite of Freemasonry, prepared for the Supreme Council of the Thirty Third Degree. The council

Local Freemasons help to keep Boys’ Town afloat

THINGS have not been as great lately for Boys' Town, situated in the inner-city Trench Town community of south St Andrew. A bronze statue of well-known cricketer O'Neil Gordon “Collie”

Harrogate & Ripon organisations benefit from Yorkshire Freemasons April grants

Harrogate & Ripon organisations benefit from Yorkshire Freemasons April grants Four community organisations in Harrogate and Ripon have benefited to the tune of £5,040 from grants presented by the freemasons.

Blackall partnership breathes new life into Masonic Lodge

To most people, Freemasonry is shrouded in mystery but part of its heritage is set to be revealed by an enterprise that until now has been western Queensland’s best kept

Does Cryptic Code Hidden in Beale Ciphers Reveal Secrets of the Freemasons?

Editor's Notes: I always enjoy these type of articles. The Beale Ciphers have challenged treasure hunters for almost 200 years. Is the Declaration of Independence the key to finding the

History: Many prominent early Fort Collins settlers were Masons

Freemasonry began centuries ago as a guild of stone workers. Guilds, precursors of unions, were invitational gatherings of skilled workers with a high level of mastery of their craft. Sometime

Telegram Channel Posts Article On Freemasons From Taliban’s ‘Shariat’ Magazine

On Telegram, a channel called Ansar Taliban ("Aiders Of The Taliban") has posted a translated article from the January 2018 issue of the Urdu monthly magazine "Shariat," which is published

Australian Freemasons join fight against domestic violence

DOMESTIC violence victims will soon be able to access more than 2000 free legal appointments each year, after Women’s Legal Service Queensland (WLSQ) received $340,000 from the state’s Masonic charity.

The Royal Family’s links to Freemasonry

It is often dubbed as one of the world’s most secret societies – the world of Freemasonry. From covert handshakes to Masonic rituals, mystery surrounds the organisation which has connections to

Winston Churchill – Freemason

There are some great Freemasons and then there are some great men who were Freemasons; Winston Churchill belong to the latter. It could be perhaps argued that Winston Churchill was

An Interview with the Russian Grand Master – Andrey Bogdanov

''At times, characters dreaming of world domination come to us" Q. Mr Bodganov, could you tell our readers how you came to Masonry and about your road to the post

Freemasons Revealed – Tercentenary Celebrations

More than 4,000 brethren from all over the world descended on London's Royal Albert Hall for the Tercentenary celebration on Tuesday, and the crowd included Masons from 136 grand lodges

The Ashlars

Do you know what ashlars are?  Most ashlars found in lodge rooms, if not all, ashlars are cubes. The question is, should they be cubes? The rough ashlar is an


A TALE OF MASONIC RESISTANCE Inscribed to R. W. Bro. John Warren Hunt, OF MADISON, WISCONSIN. THE "Morgan Affair," as it was popularly termed, or rather the Antimasonic boil, which came to

Digital Working Tools: The role of Social Media within Freemasonry

Many people are struggling to understand the place for Social Media within a fraternity that has existed for nearly three hundred years and for the last eighty years has been

Brotherhood in the 21st Century

As Freemasons we pride ourselves on the antiquity and history of the Craft, but will our ceremonies and ritual in and of themselves be enough to satisfy future generations? The

The Symbol of the Skull and Crossbones and its Masonic Application

There has been a great deal of controversy of late concerning the symbol of the skull and crossbones and whether or not it should be regarded as a legitimate Masonic

Of My Own Freewill and Accord

I’ve always been curious about the peculiar practice in Freemasonry that no man may be asked, invited, or solicited to enter the fraternity. It is an organizational feature almost unique


Mackey's Encyclopedia of Freemasonry is silent on the subject of research lodges, a circumstance easily explained by the fact that its copyrighted first edition dates from 1873, whereas Quatuor Coronati

To Infinity and Beyond – The First Lunar Lodge

On July 20, 1969, two American Astronauts landed on the moon of the planet Earth, in an area known as Mare Tranquilitatis , or “Sea of Tranquility”.  One of those

Fraternalism – The Lost Word in Charity

Any study of the beginnings of Freemasonry will clearly show that fraternalism was the first and most distinguishing characteristic of Masons and Masonry. We are, above everything else, our own

1 thought on “Of My Own Freewill and Accord”

Leave a Reply